Eight weeks into the 2026 NFL season, CBS Sports has released midseason grades for all 32 first-round picks, evaluating production, injuries, expectations, and tape study. The assessment also revisits original scouting reports and highlights 10 Day 2 and Day 3 rookies already making an impact.
First-Round Standouts
Linebackers Arvell Reese (Giants) and Sonny Styles (Commanders) both earned A+ grades. Reese has validated his Ohio State instincts and athleticism, becoming an immediate difference-maker. Styles is already trusted with defensive call responsibilities and excels in coverage against tight ends and running backs. Cornerback Mansoor Delane (Chiefs) received an A- for his technically sound play, though injuries have limited his availability. Offensive tackle Spencer Fano (Browns) also earned an A- after a smooth transition to left tackle, showcasing the footwork and balance that made him a top prospect at Utah.
Notable Struggles and Injury Concerns
Safety Caleb Downs (Cowboys) dropped to a C+ after a surprising decline; opponents have completed 20 of 24 passes against him for 230 yards and three touchdowns. Edge rusher Rueben Bain Jr. (Buccaneers) sits at a C after shoulder and groin injuries derailed his first month, though his explosive traits are reappearing. Running back Jeremiyah Love (Cardinals) received a C+ due to an ankle injury that has sidelined him since the preseason, while wide receiver Jordyn Tyson (Saints) and defensive tackle Caleb Banks (Vikings) earned incompletes because of health and limited snaps, respectively.
Day 2 and Day 3 Contributors
Among later-round picks, wide receiver Denzel Boston (Browns, Round 2) leads with 409 receiving yards and three touchdowns, earning a B+. Linebacker Jacob Rodriguez (Dolphins, Round 2) and edge rusher Gabe Jacas (Patriots, Round 2) both received A- grades for immediate defensive production. Fourth-round defensive tackle Gracen Halton (49ers) and defensive back Keionte Scott (Buccaneers) each earned A- as Day 3 steals, while fifth-round linebacker Jaden Dugger (49ers) and fourth-round linebacker Kendal Daniels (Falcons) graded B+ with significant snap counts and tackle numbers.
