Chairman of the Board: Fatma Al-FarEditor-in-Chief: Ayman Badra

Every sport. Every story.

Latest News
Articles

Three Overreactions About the New York Giants Entering Week 10 of the 2026 NFL Season

Three Overreactions About the New York Giants Entering Week 10 of the 2026 NFL Season
Articles · 10:36:21 - Sunday, 15 November 2026

The New York Giants sit atop the NFC East with a 5-2-1 record heading into Week 10 of the 2026 NFL season and are favored to defeat the Washington Commanders on Thursday night. Head coach John Harbaugh has changed the culture and mindset of the team, giving them an attacking mentality on both sides of the ball that has made them one of the league's surprise teams. With success comes scrutiny, and several overreactions have emerged around the Giants.

Overreaction 1: Giants Are a Fraudulent Division Leader

Critics argue the Giants are a fraudulent first-place team because they have yet to defeat an opponent with a winning record. New York's five wins have come against teams with a combined 13-30 record, and five of their remaining nine opponents have winning records. However, the Giants have no control over the schedule; they have already pulled off upsets against the Cowboys and Texans and are 4-1-1 in one-score games, a mark of a good team. A winning record after eight games makes them a legitimate contender, and they will have a chance to silence doubters when they face the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 11.

Overreaction 2: Mistake Not Trading for a Running Back

The NFL trade deadline passed without the Giants acquiring a running back despite their efforts. They offered the Indianapolis Colts a second- and fifth-round pick for Jonathan Taylor, but the Colts declined. ESPN's Jordan Raanan reported the Giants also reached out to the Atlanta Falcons about Bijan Robinson. General manager Joe Schoen decided not to sweeten the deal for Taylor or pursue another back. The ground game has been held under 90 yards in four games this season, leading some to view the inaction as a playoff-hindering mistake. However, the franchise has limited draft capital after giving up a fifth-round pick to acquire J.J. McCarthy and a fourth-round pick to trade up for Malachi Fields. Acquiring Taylor would likely have required a first-round pick and more for a back who turns 28 in January. Sometimes the best move is no move, and New York needs to preserve its 2027 draft capital to fill other holes.

Overreaction 3: J.J. McCarthy Will Create a Quarterback Competition with Jaxson Dart in 2027

After completing 31 of 49 passes for 495 yards with one touchdown and one interception in his first five quarters as a starter, some observers felt McCarthy had done enough to create a quarterback competition with Jaxson Dart in 2027. Even after a subpar performance against the Eagles in Week 9, that sentiment persists. But it is far too premature to think McCarthy and Dart will be in a competition at the start of training camp. The former Michigan signal-caller must lead the team into the postseason and likely win a playoff game before any serious discussions about the 2027 starter begin. Assessment should wait until at least the end of the regular season.

Share this article:FacebookXWhatsAppTelegram