The blockbuster offseason trade sending Jaylen Brown to the Philadelphia 76ers for Paul George and draft capital initially drew widespread criticism for the Boston Celtics, but early-season results have shifted the narrative. With both teams off to strong starts — Philadelphia leading the Eastern Conference at 9-2 and Boston close behind at 8-2 with the conference's best net rating (+11.6) — revised grades reflect a more favorable outlook for the Celtics.
Boston Celtics: B- (Up from D-)
The original backlash centered on two premises: that a prime All-NBA forward should command four or five first-round picks, and that George, entering his age-36 season on a supermax contract, represented negative value. However, the new collective bargaining agreement's apron constraints have altered star-trade economics. Comparable deals for Giannis Antetokounmpo (three picks, a swap, and role players) suggest Brown's return of two first-round picks and George aligns with the current cost-conscious market.
George has validated Boston's bet on his post-suspension resurgence. Through 10 games he averages 20.4 points on 47/43/81 shooting, with 4.1 assists and 2.33 steals per game. His 3-point attempt rate (51.4%) nearly doubles Brown's (27.8%), fitting Joe Mazzulla's system alongside Jayson Tatum. George also leads the league in deflections, boosting Boston's turnover generation and free-throw rate. The Celtics' average touch time has dropped from eighth-highest to sixth-lowest, reflecting faster ball movement.
Contractually, George's deal is a year shorter than the supermax extension Brown would have commanded, and his 2025-26 player option offers flexibility. Boston projects $3 million in first-apron room for 2027-28, and could restructure George's contract if he sustains this level. The grade stops at B- due to age-36 injury risk and the playoff unknown, where Brown's individual shot creation and man-to-man defense may be missed.
Philadelphia 76ers: A+ (Unchanged)
Philadelphia's acquisition of Brown was reportedly a key factor in attracting LeBron James on a minimum contract, instantly offsetting any salary concerns. Brown has embraced a reduced role: his usage rate is the lowest since 2020, turnovers halved, and he anchors a defense ranked sixth in the NBA. The 76ers' four-star starting lineup creates constant mismatches; in two games against Cleveland, James Harden and Donovan Mitchell combined for 60.6 partial possessions guarding Brown — elite defenders forced to expend energy on a non-primary scorer.
The roster retains future flexibility with four first-round picks over the next seven drafts, allowing potential pivots as Joel Embiid ages. Long-term salary management will be challenging with Maxey's impending supermax and Brown's eventual extension, but the core of Maxey, Brown, and rookie VJ Edgecombe provides a high baseline for the next 3-5 years. The trade opened an immediate championship window and secured a strong foundation for the decade.
The Celtics and 76ers meet Tuesday night (8 p.m. ET, NBC/fubo) in the first of what could be multiple high-stakes Eastern Conference clashes this season.



