San Diego Padres right-hander Mason Miller captured the inaugural Baseball Writers' Association of America National League Reliever of the Year award for the 2026 season. BBWAA voter Matt Snyder has now detailed the reasoning behind his ballot, which placed Miller first ahead of Philadelphia Phillies closer Jhoan Duran, Padres teammate Adrián Morejón, Milwaukee Brewers reliever Trevor Megill, and Pittsburgh Pirates lefty Mason Montgomery.
Ballot and Evaluation Criteria
Snyder's five-man ballot read: 1. Mason Miller (Padres), 2. Jhoan Duran (Phillies), 3. Adrián Morejón (Padres), 4. Trevor Megill (Brewers), 5. Mason Montgomery (Pirates). He explicitly disregarded win-loss records and team performance, focusing instead on run prevention (ERA, FIP, xFIP), ability to keep runners off base (WHIP), strikeout rates, workload, win probability added (WPA), wins above replacement (WAR), and the "eye test" of how imposing a reliever appears when entering a game.
Run Prevention and Base Runners
Among NL relievers, Miller led the league in ERA (1.67), expected ERA, FIP, and xFIP. Duran ranked second in those same categories, while Yuki Matsui, Brandyn Garcia, and Abner Uribe rounded out the top five. Megill placed third in FIP, Montgomery third in xFIP, and Morejón fourth. In WHIP, Garcia led all NL relievers; Megill was second, Miller third, Duran ninth, and Montgomery tenth. Workload also factored in: Morejón threw 86 innings, Miller 70, Montgomery 63⅔, Megill 61⅔, Duran 59⅓, and Garcia 51⅓.
Strikeout Dominance
Miller's strikeout numbers were historic: 129 strikeouts, a 16.6 K/9 rate, and a 47.4% strikeout percentage. Montgomery followed with a 37.7% K-rate, Duran at 35.6%, Garcia sixth, Morejón ninth, Megill 14th, Uribe 25th, and Matsui 28th.
Save and Hold Conversion
Miller tied for the league lead in saves (38-for-41 in save opportunities). Duran converted 33 of 35 chances. Megill recorded 30 saves and seven holds with three blown saves. Montgomery had 18 saves and nine holds with three blown saves. Morejón notched three saves and 28 holds but blew five saves. Uribe posted six saves and 23 holds with two blown saves. Garcia was perfect in save/hold situations (five saves, 18 holds, zero blown leads), while Matsui had one save and 10 holds without a blown lead but was used in lower-leverage spots.
WPA and WAR Analysis
Using FanGraphs WAR, Miller led at 3.7, followed by Duran (2.9), Morejón (2.8), and Megill (2.5). Baseball Reference WAR had Duran ahead at 3.4, Miller at 3.1, Montgomery at 2.4, and Uribe at 2.3. In win probability added, Miller again topped the list at 4.56, with Uribe second (3.49), Morejón third (3.23), Montgomery fourth (2.86), Megill seventh, Garcia eighth, and Duran 11th.
Final Reasoning
Snyder wrote that Miller's sweep of every major category made him an unambiguous first choice. He leaned toward Duran over Morejón for the second spot due to Duran's superior strikeout rate and run prevention, which drove his WAR lead. Morejón's heavy workload (86 innings of high-leverage work) locked him in at third. Megill's underlying metrics edged out Uribe for fourth, while Montgomery's outstanding season for the Pirates earned the fifth slot. Uribe and Garcia were described as the toughest omissions.



