Gotham FC has relocated its NWSL playoff semifinal against the Kansas City Current from Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, to Icahn Stadium on Manhattan's Randall's Island due to concerns over pitch quality and player safety. The decision came 24 hours after Gotham's 1-0 quarterfinal win over the Seattle Reign, during which coach Juan Carlos Amoros apologized for the field's condition, describing it as below standard for a league quarterfinal.
Players and coaches from both teams criticized the surface, which showed visible damage from a recent rugby doubleheader and leftover sand. Reign coach Laura Harvey called it "s---", captain Jess Fishlock deemed it "atrocious", and Gotham midfielder Jaelin Howell described it as "sandy" and "unstable". Despite a field consultant deeming the pitch FIFA-compliant on Friday, and inspections by the NWSL, referees, and players' association clearing it for Sunday's match, Gotham opted to move.
Dispute with Red Bull New York
The venue is primarily operated by MLS side Red Bull New York (RBNY), which installed a new pitch in July. RBNY declined a hybrid repair plan that would have stitched artificial threads into the grass, citing a scheduled friendly against Club América on Saturday that could not be guaranteed to proceed if work ran long. RBNY stated the pitch was cleared for all matches this season and expressed frustration over the move.
The NWSL had fined Gotham $10,000 for the field's condition after a November 1 match, even though Gotham does not manage the stadium. The fine was not widely known until Harvey mentioned it post-match.
Broader NWSL Logistical Issues
The last-minute switch highlights ongoing scheduling and venue-control challenges in the NWSL, where roughly half the teams are secondary tenants. Gotham will move to Etihad Park in 2028 but will remain a secondary tenant under New York City FC. The league's expansion and calendar alignment with MLS continue to create conflicts, as seen with the Washington Spirit also navigating venue issues for the other semifinal.



