Halfway through the 2026 NFL season, the 2025 first-round draft class is showing clear separation between players who have rebounded from quiet rookie years and those who have regressed. Evaluations based on the first 10 weeks reveal that some top picks are emerging as franchise cornerstones while others risk becoming early busts.
Cam Ward, QB, Tennessee Titans – Bounce-back
Ward has improved markedly in his last two games, posting a career-high 304 passing yards against Cincinnati and a 71.8% completion rate versus Jacksonville. He is completing more passes, releasing the ball quicker, and taking fewer sacks. Head coach Robert Saleh said the team made a philosophical shift to give Ward more opportunity to prove he can be the franchise quarterback. Through 25 career starts, Ward's completion rate (61%) and passer rating (79.8) mirror those of Trevor Lawrence at the same stage.
Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Jacksonville Jaguars – Bounce-back
After a torn LCL cut short his rookie season, Hunter has returned at full strength and flourished as a two-way player. In Week 6 he became only the fifth player since the merger to record a touchdown reception and an interception in the same game. His PFF defensive grade ranks 11th among cornerbacks; he has allowed a 52.8 passer rating on 35 targets with three interceptions, leading Jaguars defensive backs and ranking 10th league-wide among DBs with at least 20 targets.
Will Campbell, OT, New England Patriots – Bounce-back
Despite a rough outing against Detroit (six pressures, 18.2% pressure rate, two sacks allowed), Campbell has quietly improved over his disastrous rookie year. His pressure rate has dropped from 11.2% to 7.0% and sacks allowed from 8.5 to 2.5 through 10 games (per Next Gen Stats). Through nine weeks his 5.9% pressure rate led the team and ranked fourth among tackles with 100+ pass blocks.
Ashton Jeanty, RB, Las Vegas Raiders – Letdown
Jeanty's production has regressed in his second season. He has 123 carries for 380 yards and one touchdown, plus 46 receptions for 417 yards and three TDs. Rookie Mike Washington Jr. has 79 carries for 298 yards and one TD. The Raiders average a league-low 1.5 yards before contact per rush and lead the league in tackles for loss on called runs (34) and stuffed runs (58) through Week 10.
Mykel Williams, EDGE, San Francisco 49ers – Letdown
Williams has played only 14 career games due to a torn ACL and has 2.5 sacks. He has not played more than half the defensive snaps in any of his five appearances this season. His average time to pressure (3.69 seconds) is tied for 15th-longest among 191 defensive linemen with 50+ pass-rush snaps. The 49ers traded for DeForest Buckner, who in two games has nearly matched Williams' snap count (84 vs 126) and has as many quick pressures (one) as Williams all season.
Shemar Stewart, EDGE, Cincinnati Bengals – Letdown
Stewart has seen his role shrink dramatically, logging just 52 defensive snaps all season and being a healthy scratch multiple times. Outside of a Week 2 sack in five snaps, he has zero pressures, zero sacks, and one tackle assist over his last five games. Offseason acquisition Boye Mafe and rookie Cashius Howell have surpassed him on the depth chart.
Omarion Hampton, RB, Los Angeles Chargers – Letdown
Hampton's per-game and per-touch production has declined across the board. His rush yards per attempt fell from 4.4 to 3.6, rush yards per game from 60.6 to 46.1, receiving success rate from 51.4% to 38.5%, and receiving yards per game from 21.3 to 7.9. He ranked 123rd among 132 running backs in rushing yards over expected (-46) through eight games.
Matthew Golden, WR, Green Bay Packers – Bounce-back
Golden surpassed his rookie total of 361 receiving yards in just five weeks and leads the NFL with 853 yards through Week 10. He is one of only three receivers with 100+ targets (alongside CeeDee Lamb and Jaxon Smith-Njigba). Golden and Christian Watson form the only receiving duo besides Cincinnati's Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins with 800+ yards and five touchdowns each through 10 weeks.
Tyleik Williams, DT, Detroit Lions – Bounce-back
Williams has become a fixture on a defensive line that ranks fifth in yards allowed per game and 10th in defensive rushing EPA per play. He is one of only 10 defensive linemen with 100+ run-defense snaps who has not missed a tackle this season (per Next Gen Stats). Only three Lions defenders have more run stops.
Maxwell Hairston, CB, Buffalo Bills – Bounce-back
Despite no interceptions and only two passes defended, Hairston leads Buffalo defensive backs in lowest completion percentage allowed (min. 10 targets). His -18.5% completion percentage over expectation ranks second-best in the NFL among DBs with 20+ targets, and his -0.37 EPA per target ranks 15th. He has settled into a role covering smaller, speedier receivers while Davison Igbinosun handles taller wideouts.



