Chairman of the Board: Fatma Al-FarEditor-in-Chief: Ayman Badra

Every sport. Every story.

Latest News
Articles

CFP Rankings Under Scrutiny: Alabama's No. 3 Spot Defies Metrics, Indiana Deserves Higher

CFP Rankings Under Scrutiny: Alabama's No. 3 Spot Defies Metrics, Indiana Deserves Higher
Articles · 21:57:02 - Sunday, 22 November 2026

The latest College Football Playoff rankings have sparked debate over the selection committee's consistency, with Alabama remaining at No. 3 despite a weekend that saw all six SEC opponents it defeated lose, while Indiana dropped five spots a week earlier under similar circumstances. Committee chair Hunter Yurachek cited Alabama's consistency and average conference victory margin of nearly 23 points as the separator over Texas, even though the Longhorns hold more top-25 wins and lead in strength of schedule, strength of record, and game control metrics.

Overrated: Alabama

Alabama's best wins are over No. 16 Kentucky and No. 21 South Carolina, while Texas boasts victories over No. 9 Tennessee, No. 14 Ohio State, and No. 25 Ole Miss, and knocked LSU out of the rankings. The committee's emphasis on the "eye test" and margin of victory over a mountain of resume metrics raises questions about the validity of the top-four placement.

Underrated: Texas

Texas, ranked No. 5 with two losses, possesses the strongest resume among two-loss SEC teams and should be in line for a playoff bye. The Longhorns' schedule strength and quality wins surpass Alabama's, yet they remain behind the Crimson Tide.

Overrated: Ohio State

The Buckeyes jumped six spots to No. 14 after a nine-point win over unranked Northwestern, benefiting from attrition above them. Without Julian Sayin and having lost to USC and Oregon, the current Ohio State team appears vulnerable, though talent like receiver Jeremiah Smith keeps them in playoff contention if other teams falter.

Underrated: Indiana

Indiana rose only one spot to No. 9 after a 27-13 win over No. 18 USC. Coach Curt Cignetti's criticism of the committee may not have helped, but the Hoosiers' lone loss came against a full-strength Ohio State squad, and their dominant defense is championship-caliber. The previous drop from No. 4 to No. 9 felt like an overcorrection that was not fully rectified this week.

Overrated: South Carolina

South Carolina remains at No. 21 despite a 34-6 loss to Arkansas without quarterback LaNorris Sellers. The presence of four-loss SEC teams South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss in the rankings fuels criticism of SEC bias, especially when four-loss Big Ten teams like Illinois and Northwestern are excluded, and Group of Six contenders Liberty and Memphis are left out. South Carolina's ranking also bolsters Alabama's resume by providing another top-25 win.

Share this article:FacebookXWhatsAppTelegram