The College Football Playoff selection committee released its second rankings of the season on Tuesday, sparking debate over the placement of several teams. Alabama climbed two spots to No. 3 despite a 7-2 record and a head-to-head loss to Tennessee, making the Crimson Tide the highest-ranked two-loss team in CFP history. Tennessee, which owns the same record and a 26-10 victory over Alabama, sits at No. 8.
Overrated: Alabama
Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek cited Alabama's strength of record and schedule, noting four "quality wins," including a victory at Mississippi State when the Bulldogs were 4-0. However, the Tide's three top-25 wins have diminished in luster: Kentucky has since been beaten by 28 points twice, South Carolina has three losses, and LSU is 0-3 against the top 25. Alabama sits ahead of unbeaten UCLA and one-loss Notre Dame, which just defeated No. 1 Miami.
Frustrated: Indiana
Idle on a bye week, Indiana fell five spots to No. 9, the largest drop for an idle team in the CFP's 13-year history. The previous largest was three spots. Committee chair Yurachek said the Hoosiers were "probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time," noting that Big Ten opponents on Indiana's schedule went a combined 0-8 last week. Indiana hosts No. 18 USC on Saturday.
Overrated: Missouri
Four SEC teams with three losses are ranked: South Carolina (No. 17), Ole Miss (No. 19), LSU (No. 21), and Missouri (No. 22). They are a combined 3-9 against the current top 25, with LSU and Missouri a combined 0-5. Missouri lost to unranked Mississippi State, was blown out at Ole Miss, and lost by 14 at home to Texas. The AP poll did not rank the Tigers.
Underrated: Tennessee
The Volunteers are 2-2 against the top 25 with wins over No. 3 Alabama and No. 11 Kentucky by a combined 44 points. Their two losses came by a combined six points to No. 6 Texas and No. 17 South Carolina. The committee's protocol lists head-to-head results second among comparison principles, yet Tennessee trails Alabama by five spots.
Underrated: Texas Tech
The Red Raiders are the first team out at No. 12, two spots below their AP ranking. At 8-1 with top-25 wins over No. 14 Houston and No. 23 Arizona, Texas Tech has as many ranked wins as Kentucky with one fewer loss. Their only blemish is a loss at unranked Cincinnati. They face No. 25 Oklahoma State on Saturday.
Underrated: New Mexico and Boise State
New Mexico is 8-1, ranked No. 23 by the AP but unranked by the committee for a second straight week. The Lobos' only loss was at Oklahoma, which has since beaten Texas and won at Florida. New Mexico leads the nation in scoring defense. Boise State holds the Group of Six spot at No. 24, seven spots lower than its AP ranking, the largest gap between the two polls. The Broncos' only loss came at full-strength Oregon in the opener.
Underrated: Notre Dame
Despite a historic six-spot jump to No. 5 after beating Miami, Notre Dame remains one spot short of a first-round bye and two spots below its AP ranking. The Irish are 1-1 against the top 25 with a controversial loss at No. 10 BYU. With only Boston College, SMU, and Syracuse remaining, and no conference championship game, Notre Dame may stay at No. 5 until Selection Sunday.


